| | | West Chester wins toss, they defer. Ship will receive. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship35 | WCU ball on WCU35. |
| | | Alex Walsh kickoff 57 yards to the SHIP8, James Rockymore return 15 yards to the SHIP23 (Brett Paterson;Tyler Downes). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship23 | David Richards rush for 15 yards to the SHIP38, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Chris Tagye;Lateef Ferguson). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship38 | PENALTY SHIP false start 5 yards to the SHIP33. |
| Ship | 1-15 | at Ship33 | Aaron Dykes rush for 3 yards to the SHIP36 (Chris Tagye;Jimmy Lewis). |
| Ship | 2-12 | at Ship36 | Tony Gomez pass complete to Howard Chavous for 5 yards to the SHIP41 (Rashad Grimsley). |
| Ship | 3-7 | at Ship41 | Team rush for loss of 17 yards to the SHIP24 (Chris Tagye). |
| Ship | 4-24 | at Ship24 | Kyler Ford punt 40 yards to the WCU36, Mike Washington return 2 yards to the WCU38 (J. Aldridge). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 1 yards, TOP 02:37 |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu38 | WEST CHESTER drive start at 12:23. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu38 | Osagie Osunde rush for 3 yards to the WCU41. |
| Wcu | 2-7 | at Wcu41 | Bill Zwaan pass incomplete to Eric Ruffenach. |
| Wcu | 3-7 | at Wcu41 | Bill Zwaan pass incomplete to Eric Ruffenach. |
| Wcu | 4-7 | at Wcu41 | Anthony Belasco punt 54 yards to the SHIP5, Pat Ferguson return 10 yards to the SHIP15 (Mike Dell;Mike Mignogno). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 01:05 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship15 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 11:18. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship15 | Chris Infante rush for 2 yards to the SHIP17 (James Thorpe;Lateef Ferguson). |
| Ship | 2-8 | at Ship17 | Tony Gomez rush for 3 yards to the SHIP20 (Chris Tagye). |
| Ship | 3-5 | at Ship20 | Tony Gomez pass incomplete to Tim Devanney, PENALTY WCU personal foul 15 yards to the SHIP35, 1ST DOWN SHIP. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship35 | 1st and 10. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship35 | David Richards rush for no gain to the SHIP35 (Lateef Ferguson;Jimmy Lewis). |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Ship35 | Chris Infante rush for 7 yards to the SHIP42 (Mike Dell;Chris Tagye). |
| Ship | 3-3 | at Ship42 | David Richards rush for 4 yards to the SHIP46, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Mike Mignogno;Anthony Gallup). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship46 | Walter Crump rush for no gain to the SHIP46 (Lateef Ferguson). |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Ship46 | Tony Gomez pass complete to Walter Crump for 6 yards to the WCU48 (Anthony Belasco). |
| Ship | 3-4 | at Wcu48 | Tony Gomez pass incomplete to Tim Devanney. |
| Ship | 4-4 | at Wcu48 | Kyler Ford punt 34 yards to the WCU14, fair catch by Tyler Downes. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 37 yards, TOP 04:17 |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu14 | WEST CHESTER drive start at 07:01. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu14 | Osagie Osunde rush for 1 yard to the WCU15 (Bill Morrison;Josh Emberg). |
| Wcu | 2-9 | at Wcu15 | Osagie Osunde rush for loss of 1 yard to the WCU14 (Jaron Nalewak;Frank Duffy). |
| Wcu | 3-10 | at Wcu14 | Bill Zwaan pass complete to Mike Washington for 38 yards to the SHIP48, 1ST DOWN WCU (Dee Wolford). |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Ship48 | Mike Washington rush for 3 yards to the SHIP45 (J. Aldridge). |
| Wcu | 2-7 | at Ship45 | Osagie Osunde rush for loss of 2 yards to the SHIP47 (Jaron Nalewak). |
| Wcu | 3-9 | at Ship47 | Bill Zwaan pass complete to Cody Clark for 19 yards to the SHIP28, 1ST DOWN WCU (Reggie Farrior). |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Ship28 | Osagie Osunde rush for no gain to the SHIP28 (Frank Duffy;Reggie Farrior). |
| Wcu | 2-10 | at Ship28 | Osagie Osunde rush for loss of 3 yards to the SHIP31 (Matt Kosciolek). |
| Wcu | 3-13 | at Ship31 | Bill Zwaan pass incomplete to Cody Clark. |
| Wcu | 4-13 | at Ship31 | Bill Zwaan pass complete to Eric Ruffenach for 31 yards to the SHIP0, 1ST DOWN WCU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:28. |
| | | Alex Walsh kick attempt good. |
| | | West Chester 7, Shippensburg 0 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 86 yards, TOP 05:33 |
| | | Alex Walsh kickoff 57 yards to the SHIP8, James Rockymore return 17 yards to the SHIP25 (T.J. Cascio). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship25 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 01:16. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship25 | Tony Gomez pass incomplete to Dave Wilkerson. |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Ship25 | Aaron Dykes rush for 1 yard to the SHIP26 (Jimmy Lewis;Nick Jablokov). |
| Ship | 3-9 | at Ship26 | Tony Gomez sacked for loss of 1 yard to the SHIP25 (Jimmy Lewis;Lateef Ferguson). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 01:25 |
| | | West Chester 7, Shippensburg 0 |
| Ship | 4-10 | at Ship25 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Ship | 4-10 | at Ship25 | Kyler Ford punt 25 yards to the 50 yardline, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 01:25 |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu50 | WEST CHESTER drive start at 14:51. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu50 | Bill Zwaan pass complete to Mike Washington for 50 yards to the SHIP0, clock 14:42, PENALTY WCU illegal procedure 5 yards to the WCU45, NO PLAY. |
| Wcu | 1-15 | at Wcu45 | Bill Zwaan sacked for loss of 5 yards to the WCU40 (Josh Emberg). |
| Wcu | 2-20 | at Wcu40 | Bill Zwaan pass incomplete to Osagie Osunde. |
| Wcu | 3-20 | at Wcu40 | Bill Zwaan pass incomplete to Mike Washington. |
| Wcu | 4-20 | at Wcu40 | Anthony Belasco punt 42 yards to the SHIP18, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 10 yards, TOP 01:37 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship18 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 13:14. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship18 | David Richards rush for no gain to the SHIP18 (Michael Walter). |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Ship18 | Walter Crump rush for 2 yards to the SHIP20, fumble forced by Vlad. Garbovsky, fumble by Walter Crump recovered by WCU Tyler Downes at SHIP24. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 6 yards, TOP 00:50 |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Ship24 | WEST CHESTER drive start at 12:24. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Ship24 | Osagie Osunde rush for 1 yard to the SHIP23 (Matt Kosciolek). |
| Wcu | 2-9 | at Ship23 | Bill Zwaan rush for 19 yards to the SHIP4, 1ST DOWN WCU (James Rockymore). |
| Wcu | 1-G | at Ship04 | Osagie Osunde rush for 1 yard to the SHIP3 (Jaron Nalewak). |
| Wcu | 2-G | at Ship03 | Osagie Osunde rush for 3 yards to the SHIP0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:27. |
| | | Alex Walsh kick attempt good. |
| | | West Chester 14, Shippensburg 0 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 24 yards, TOP 01:57 |
| | | Alex Walsh kickoff 57 yards to the SHIP8, Howard Chavous return 17 yards to the SHIP25 (T.J. Cascio). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship25 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 10:15. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship25 | Gabe Maiocco pass complete to Pat Ferguson for 9 yards to the SHIP34 (Rashad Grimsley). |
| Ship | 2-1 | at Ship34 | Aaron Dykes rush for 6 yards to the SHIP40, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Brett Paterson;James Thorpe). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship40 | Dave Wilkerson rush for no gain to the SHIP40 (Anthony Gallup;Joe Cefalo). |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Ship40 | Gabe Maiocco pass complete to Pat Ferguson for 11 yards to the WCU49, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Brett Paterson). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Wcu49 | Gabe Maiocco pass incomplete to Dave Wilkerson. |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Wcu49 | Aaron Dykes rush for 2 yards to the WCU47 (Joe Cefalo;James Thorpe). |
| Ship | 3-8 | at Wcu47 | Gabe Maiocco pass complete to David Richards for 11 yards to the WCU36, 1ST DOWN SHIP. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Wcu36 | Gabe Maiocco sacked for loss of 9 yards to the WCU45 (Dave Montgomery). |
| Ship | 2-19 | at Wcu45 | Gabe Maiocco pass incomplete to Howard Chavous. |
| Ship | 3-19 | at Wcu45 | Gabe Maiocco pass intercepted by Jimmy Lewis at the WCU33, Jimmy Lewis return 22 yards to the SHIP45 (Gabe Maiocco). |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 30 yards, TOP 04:35 |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Ship45 | WEST CHESTER drive start at 05:40. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Ship45 | Matt Burdalski pass complete to Dean Millard for 45 yards to the SHIP0, 1ST DOWN WCU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 05:08. |
| | | Alex Walsh kick attempt good. |
| | | West Chester 21, Shippensburg 0 |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 45 yards, TOP 00:32 |
| | | Alex Walsh kickoff 54 yards to the SHIP11, Howard Chavous return 9 yards to the SHIP20 (Brett Paterson;Jeff Broyan), PENALTY WCU personal foul 15 yards to the SHIP35, 1st and 10, SHIP ball on SHIP35. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship35 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 04:56. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship35 | Aaron Dykes rush for no gain to the SHIP35 (Glenn Walrath). |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Ship35 | Gabe Maiocco pass complete to David Richards for 13 yards to the SHIP48, 1ST DOWN SHIP (T.J. Cascio). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship48 | Gabe Maiocco pass incomplete to Walter Crump. |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Ship48 | Gabe Maiocco pass complete to Howard Chavous for 9 yards to the WCU43 (Lateef Ferguson;Rashad Grimsley). |
| Ship | 3-1 | at Wcu43 | PENALTY SHIP false start 5 yards to the WCU48. |
| Ship | 3-6 | at Wcu48 | Gabe Maiocco pass incomplete to Pat Ferguson (Rashad Grimsley). |
| Ship | 4-6 | at Wcu48 | Kyler Ford punt 32 yards to the WCU16, fair catch by Tyler Downes. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 17 yards, TOP 02:38 |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu16 | WEST CHESTER drive start at 02:18. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu16 | Osagie Osunde rush for 6 yards to the WCU22 (John Sharbaugh;Bill Morrison). |
| Wcu | 2-4 | at Wcu22 | Timeout West Chester, clock 01:47. |
| Wcu | 2-4 | at Wcu22 | Bill Zwaan sacked for loss of 7 yards to the WCU15 (Jaron Nalewak). |
| Wcu | 3-11 | at Wcu15 | Timeout West Chester, clock 00:59. |
| Wcu | 3-11 | at Wcu15 | Bill Zwaan pass incomplete to Cody Clark. |
| Wcu | 4-11 | at Wcu15 | Anthony Belasco punt 42 yards to the SHIP43, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 01:38 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship43 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 00:40. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship43 | Gabe Maiocco pass incomplete to Tim Devanney. |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Ship43 | Gabe Maiocco pass intercepted by Joe Cefalo at the SHIP47, Joe Cefalo return 0 yards to the SHIP47, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:22 |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Ship47 | WEST CHESTER drive start at 00:18. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Ship47 | Bill Zwaan pass complete to Mike Washington for 30 yards to the SHIP17, 1ST DOWN WCU (Matt Kosciolek). |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Ship17 | TEAM pass incomplete. |
| Wcu | 2-10 | at Ship17 | Alex Walsh field goal attempt from 33 GOOD, clock 00:00. |
| | | West Chester 24, Shippensburg 0 |
| Wcu | 1-G | at Wcu35 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| Wcu | 1-G | at Wcu35 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 30 yards, TOP 00:18 |
| | | West Chester 24, Shippensburg 0 |
| Wcu | 1-G | at Wcu35 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, SHIP ball on SHIP35. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 30 yards, TOP 00:18 |
| | | Jamie Reder kickoff 64 yards to the WCU1, Mike Washington return 20 yards to the WCU21 (J. Aldridge;Josh Oswalt). |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu21 | WEST CHESTER drive start at 14:48. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu21 | Osagie Osunde rush for loss of 2 yards to the WCU19 (Bill Morrison). |
| Wcu | 2-12 | at Wcu19 | Bill Zwaan pass complete to Mike Washington for 15 yards to the WCU34, 1ST DOWN WCU. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu34 | Osagie Osunde rush for no gain to the WCU34 (Bill Morrison). |
| Wcu | 2-10 | at Wcu34 | Bill Zwaan pass complete to Erik Pedersen for 8 yards to the WCU42 (John Sharbaugh). |
| Wcu | 3-2 | at Wcu42 | Osagie Osunde rush for loss of 3 yards to the WCU39 (Jaron Nalewak). |
| Wcu | 4-5 | at Wcu39 | Anthony Belasco punt 38 yards to the SHIP23, Pat Ferguson return 4 yards to the SHIP27 (T.J. Cascio). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 18 yards, TOP 02:59 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship27 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 11:49. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship27 | David Richards rush for no gain to the SHIP27 (Joe Cefalo;Chris Tagye). |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Ship27 | Tony Gomez pass complete to David Richards for 31 yards to the WCU42, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Anthony Belasco). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Wcu42 | Tony Gomez pass incomplete to Howard Chavous. |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Wcu42 | PENALTY SHIP false start (Tony Gomez) 5 yards to the WCU47. |
| Ship | 2-15 | at Wcu47 | Tony Gomez pass incomplete to Pat Ferguson, QB hurry by Jimmy Lewis. |
| Ship | 3-15 | at Wcu47 | Dave Wilkerson rush for 2 yards to the WCU45 (Anthony Gallup;Chris Tagye). |
| Ship | 4-13 | at Wcu45 | Kyler Ford punt 45 yards to the WCU0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 28 yards, TOP 02:21 |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu20 | WEST CHESTER drive start at 09:28. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu20 | Pat McDermott rush for 9 yards to the WCU29 (J. Aldridge). |
| Wcu | 2-1 | at Wcu29 | Osagie Osunde rush for 3 yards to the WCU32, 1ST DOWN WCU (Dee Wolford;Josh Oswalt). |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu32 | Bill Zwaan pass incomplete to Mike Washington (Reggie Farrior). |
| Wcu | 2-10 | at Wcu32 | Pat McDermott rush for 5 yards to the WCU37 (J. Aldridge;Josh Oswalt). |
| Wcu | 3-5 | at Wcu37 | Bill Zwaan pass incomplete to Mike Washington. |
| Wcu | 4-5 | at Wcu37 | Anthony Belasco punt 38 yards to the SHIP25, downed. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 17 yards, TOP 02:35 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship25 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 06:53. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship25 | David Richards rush for 3 yards to the SHIP28 (Jimmy Lewis;Chris Tagye). |
| Ship | 2-7 | at Ship28 | Tony Gomez pass incomplete to Howard Chavous. |
| Ship | 3-7 | at Ship28 | Timeout Shippensburg, clock 05:53. |
| Ship | 3-7 | at Ship28 | Tony Gomez pass incomplete to Howard Chavous, QB hurry by Lateef Ferguson. |
| Ship | 4-7 | at Ship28 | Kyler Ford punt 52 yards to the WCU20, Mike Washington return 7 yards to the WCU27 (Josh Oswalt). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 01:25 |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu27 | WEST CHESTER drive start at 05:28. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu27 | Osagie Osunde rush for 6 yards to the WCU33 (John Sharbaugh). |
| Wcu | 2-4 | at Wcu33 | PENALTY WCU false start 5 yards to the WCU28. |
| Wcu | 2-9 | at Wcu28 | Bill Zwaan pass incomplete to Mike Washington (J. Aldridge). |
| Wcu | 3-9 | at Wcu28 | Bill Zwaan pass incomplete to Mike Washington, PENALTY SHIP pass interference (Matt Kosciolek) 15 yards to the WCU43, 1ST DOWN WCU, NO PLAY. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu43 | Osagie Osunde rush for 2 yards to the WCU45 (Frank Duffy;Bill Morrison). |
| Wcu | 2-8 | at Wcu45 | Osagie Osunde rush for 3 yards to the WCU48 (Bill Morrison;Josh Emberg), PENALTY WCU holding 11 yards to the WCU34, NO PLAY, PENALTY SHIP personal foul 16 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN WCU, NO PLAY. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu50 | Osagie Osunde rush for 3 yards to the SHIP47 (Bill Morrison;Antoine Parks). |
| Wcu | 2-7 | at Ship47 | Bill Zwaan pass complete to Eric Ruffenach for 6 yards to the SHIP41 (John Sharbaugh). |
| Wcu | 3-1 | at Ship41 | PENALTY WCU false start 5 yards to the SHIP46. |
| Wcu | 3-6 | at Ship46 | PENALTY WCU false start 5 yards to the WCU49. |
| Wcu | 3-11 | at Wcu49 | Bill Zwaan pass incomplete to Eric Ruffenach. |
| Wcu | 4-11 | at Wcu49 | Anthony Belasco punt 30 yards to the SHIP21, fair catch by Pat Ferguson. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 22 yards, TOP 04:34 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship21 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 00:54. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship21 | Tony Gomez sacked for loss of 6 yards to the SHIP15 (Nick Jablokov). |
| Ship | 2-16 | at Ship15 | Tony Gomez pass complete to Kyle Fogarty for 7 yards to the SHIP22 (Rashad Grimsley;Greg Smith). |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 1 yards, TOP 03:24 |
| | | West Chester 24, Shippensburg 0 |
| Ship | 3-9 | at Ship22 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Ship | 3-9 | at Ship22 | Tony Gomez pass complete to Mark Rossi for 11 yards to the SHIP33, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Brett Paterson). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship33 | David Richards rush for 17 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN SHIP (T.J. Cascio). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship50 | Aaron Dykes rush for 2 yards to the WCU48 (Chris Tagye;Joe Cefalo). |
| Ship | 2-8 | at Wcu48 | Dave Wilkerson rush for 3 yards to the WCU45 (Lateef Ferguson). |
| Ship | 3-5 | at Wcu45 | Tony Gomez pass complete to David Richards for 20 yards to the WCU25, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Jimmy Lewis). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Wcu25 | Tony Gomez pass incomplete to Dave Wilkerson, QB hurry by Dave Montgomery. |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Wcu25 | Tony Gomez pass intercepted by Brett Paterson at the WCU14, Brett Paterson return 1 yards to the WCU15 (Dave Wilkerson). |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 54 yards, TOP 03:24 |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu15 | WEST CHESTER drive start at 12:30. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu15 | Dean Millard rush for 3 yards to the WCU18 (Michael Apgar). |
| Wcu | 2-7 | at Wcu18 | Dean Millard rush for 8 yards to the WCU26, 1ST DOWN WCU (Bill Morrison). |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu26 | Matt Burdalski pass complete to Eric Ruffenach for 11 yards to the WCU37, 1ST DOWN WCU. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu37 | Eric Ruffenach rush for 36 yards to the SHIP27, 1ST DOWN WCU (Reggie Farrior;Bill Morrison). |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Ship27 | Dean Millard rush for 5 yards to the SHIP22 (Reggie Farrior;John Sharbaugh). |
| Wcu | 2-5 | at Ship22 | Cody Clark rush for 2 yards to the SHIP20 (J. Aldridge). |
| Wcu | 3-3 | at Ship20 | Matt Burdalski pass incomplete to Mike Washington. |
| Wcu | 4-3 | at Ship20 | Timeout West Chester, clock 08:12. |
| Wcu | 4-3 | at Ship20 | Matt Burdalski pass incomplete to Eric Ruffenach. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 65 yards, TOP 04:25 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship20 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 08:05. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship20 | Gabe Maiocco sacked for loss of 5 yards to the SHIP15 (T.J. Cascio). |
| Ship | 2-15 | at Ship15 | Gabe Maiocco pass complete to Kyle Fogarty for 7 yards to the SHIP22 (Lateef Ferguson). |
| Ship | 3-8 | at Ship22 | Gabe Maiocco pass complete to David Richards for 3 yards to the SHIP25 (Ryan Kahanic), PENALTY WCU personal foul 15 yards to the SHIP40, 1ST DOWN SHIP. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship40 | 1st and 10. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship40 | Gabe Maiocco pass incomplete to Pat Ferguson (Rashad Grimsley). |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Ship40 | Gabe Maiocco pass complete to Howard Chavous for 17 yards to the WCU43, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Glenn Walrath). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Wcu43 | Gabe Maiocco pass incomplete to Pat Ferguson (Tyler Downes). |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Wcu43 | Gabe Maiocco pass complete to Tim Devanney for 15 yards to the WCU28, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Greg Smith). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Wcu28 | Gabe Maiocco pass incomplete to Howard Chavous. |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Wcu28 | Aaron Dykes rush for 3 yards to the WCU25 (Vlad. Garbovsky;Glenn Walrath). |
| Ship | 3-7 | at Wcu25 | Gabe Maiocco sacked for loss of 7 yards to the WCU32 (Vlad. Garbovsky). |
| Ship | 4-14 | at Wcu32 | Gabe Maiocco pass incomplete to Howard Chavous (Jeff Broyan). |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 48 yards, TOP 04:27 |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu32 | PENALTY SHIP illegal procedure declined. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu32 | WEST CHESTER drive start at 03:38. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu32 | Lee Hopkins rush for 4 yards to the WCU36 (Michael Apgar), PENALTY WCU personal foul 15 yards to the WCU21. |
| Wcu | 1-21 | at Wcu21 | 2nd and 21. |
| Wcu | 2-21 | at Wcu21 | Lee Hopkins rush for no gain to the WCU21 (Josh Emberg). |
| Wcu | 3-21 | at Wcu21 | Pat McDermott rush for 3 yards to the WCU24 (Jaron Nalewak). |
| Wcu | 4-18 | at Wcu24 | Timeout West Chester, clock 01:09. |
| Wcu | 4-18 | at Wcu24 | Anthony Belasco punt 39 yards to the SHIP37, Pat Ferguson return 1 yards to the SHIP38 (T.J. Cascio), PENALTY SHIP holding 10 yards to the SHIP28, 1st and 10, SHIP ball on SHIP28. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 8 yards, TOP 02:41 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship28 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 00:57. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship28 | Chad DiFebbo sacked for loss of 5 yards to the SHIP23 (Vlad. Garbovsky). |
| Ship | 2-15 | at Ship23 | Chad DiFebbo pass complete to Pat Ferguson for 14 yards to the SHIP37. |
| Ship | 3-1 | at Ship37 | Chad DiFebbo pass incomplete to Tim Devanney. |
| Ship | 4-1 | at Ship37 | Chad DiFebbo pass intercepted by Corey Rhood at the WCU17, Corey Rhood return -12 yards to the WCU5 (Pat Ferguson). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 9 yards, TOP 00:52 |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu05 | WEST CHESTER drive start at 00:05. |
| Wcu | 1-10 | at Wcu05 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | West Chester 24, Shippensburg 0 |