| | | Ship wins the coin toss and defers |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship30 | SHIP ball on SHIP30, Kyler Ford kickoff 62 yards to the CHEY8, Jason Kindell return 14 yards to the CHEY22 (M. Sammons). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey22 | Angel Rodriquez rush for 17 yards to the CHEY39, 1ST DOWN CHEY (J. McCollough). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey39 | Ron Hunter rush for 3 yards to the CHEY42 (Vinnie Ranauto). |
| Chey | 2-7 | at Chey42 | Norm Belton rush for 2 yards to the CHEY44 (Erik Van Ness). |
| Chey | 3-5 | at Chey44 | Angel Rodriquez pass incomplete to Darnell Burton. |
| Chey | 4-5 | at Chey44 | William Winter punt 23 yards to the SHIP33, downed. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 22 yards, TOP 01:47 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship33 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 13:13. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship33 | Chad DiFebbo pass incomplete to Mike Harris (Stan Banks). |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Ship33 | Mike Frenette rush for 3 yards to the SHIP36 (Jack Petion). |
| Ship | 3-7 | at Ship36 | Chad DiFebbo pass intercepted by Joseph Morris at the SHIP48, Joseph Morris return 5 yards to the SHIP43 (S. Hohenwarter). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:52 |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Ship43 | CHEYNEY drive start at 12:21. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Ship43 | Angel Rodriquez rush for 5 yards to the SHIP38 (Nick Melusky). |
| Chey | 2-5 | at Ship38 | Ron Hunter rush for 1 yard to the SHIP37 (Zach Collins). |
| Chey | 3-4 | at Ship37 | Fumble by recovered by SHIP Erik Van Ness at SHIP37. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:31 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship37 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 10:50. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship37 | Kevin Herod rush for 6 yards to the SHIP43 (Joseph Morris). |
| Ship | 2-4 | at Ship43 | Chad DiFebbo sacked for loss of 4 yards to the SHIP39 (James Parker). |
| Ship | 3-8 | at Ship39 | Chad DiFebbo rush for 6 yards to the SHIP45 (Demel Chambers). |
| Ship | 4-2 | at Ship45 | Riley Bowen rush for 9 yards to the CHEY46 (Hannbal Flores), PENALTY SHIP personal foul 16 yards to the SHIP38. |
| Ship | 4-9 | at Ship38 | 1st and 10. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship38 | Mike Frenette rush for 17 yards to the CHEY45, 1ST DOWN SHIP, out-of-bounds (Ronnell Kennedy). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey45 | Kevin Herod rush for 18 yards to the CHEY27, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Demel Chambers;Ronnell Kennedy). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey27 | Fumble by recovered by SHIP TEAM at CHEY28, PENALTY CHEY offside 4 yards to the CHEY23, NO PLAY. |
| Ship | 1-6 | at Chey23 | Kevin Herod rush for 3 yards to the CHEY20 (Bryan Payne;Ben Thompson). |
| Ship | 2-3 | at Chey20 | Kevin Herod rush for 3 yards to the CHEY17, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Demel Chambers). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey17 | Kevin Herod rush for 2 yards to the CHEY15 (Jack Petion). |
| Ship | 2-8 | at Chey15 | Chad DiFebbo pass complete to Mike Frenette for 7 yards to the CHEY8 (Stan Banks;Joseph Morris). |
| Ship | 3-1 | at Chey08 | Kevin Herod rush for 4 yards to the CHEY4, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Joseph Morris). |
| Ship | 1-G | at Chey04 | Mike Frenette rush for 4 yards to the CHEY0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:06. |
| | | Kyler Ford kick attempt good. |
| | | Shippensburg 7, Cheyney 0 |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 63 yards, TOP 06:44 |
| | | Kyler Ford kickoff 61 yards to the CHEY9, John Newman return 14 yards to the CHEY23 (Riley Bowen). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey23 | CHEYNEY drive start at 03:58. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey23 | Timeout Shippensburg, clock 03:58. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey23 | John Newman rush for 75 yards to the SHIP2, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Travis Proctor). |
| Chey | 1-G | at Ship02 | Ron Hunter rush for loss of 2 yards to the SHIP4 (Taylor Davis). |
| Chey | 2-G | at Ship04 | Angel Rodriquez rush for 4 yards to the SHIP0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:41. |
| | | Tyler Wilkinson kick attempt good. |
| | | Shippensburg 7, Cheyney 7 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 77 yards, TOP 01:17 |
| | | Tyler Wilkinson kickoff 33 yards to the SHIP37, downed. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship37 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 02:40. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship37 | Kevin Herod rush for 1 yard to the SHIP38 (Joseph Morris). |
| Ship | 2-9 | at Ship38 | Mike Frenette rush for 5 yards to the SHIP43 (Joseph Morris). |
| Ship | 3-4 | at Ship43 | Chad DiFebbo pass complete to Kevin Herod for 10 yards to the CHEY47, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Bryan Payne). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey47 | Chad DiFebbo pass incomplete to Chase DiFebbo. |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Chey47 | Kevin Marshall rush for 3 yards to the CHEY44 (Demel Chambers). |
| Ship | 3-7 | at Chey44 | Chad DiFebbo pass incomplete to Mike Frenette (Demel Chambers). |
| Ship | 4-7 | at Chey44 | Kyler Ford punt 35 yards to the CHEY9, downed. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 19 yards, TOP 02:36 |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey09 | CHEYNEY drive start at 00:04. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey09 | Angel Rodriquez rush for 8 yards to the CHEY17 (Taylor Davis). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:26 |
| | | Shippensburg 7, Cheyney 7 |
| Chey | 2-2 | at Chey17 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Chey | 2-2 | at Chey17 | John Newman rush for loss of 1 yard to the CHEY16 (Erik Van Ness), PENALTY CHEY illegal block 8 yards to the CHEY8. |
| Chey | 2-11 | at Chey08 | 2nd and 11. |
| Chey | 2-11 | at Chey08 | Kareem Shelton rush for loss of 2 yards to the CHEY6 (Nick Melusky). |
| Chey | 3-13 | at Chey06 | Angel Rodriquez pass incomplete to John Newman. |
| Chey | 4-13 | at Chey06 | David Irizarry punt 27 yards to the CHEY33, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 3 yards, TOP 01:26 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey33 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 13:38. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey33 | Roshaan McCain rush for loss of 8 yards to the CHEY41 (Franklin Lyburn). |
| Ship | 2-18 | at Chey41 | Kevin Herod rush for 2 yards to the CHEY39 (Darryl Wilkins). |
| Ship | 3-16 | at Chey39 | Chad DiFebbo rush for 5 yards to the CHEY34 (Joseph Morris), PENALTY CHEY offside 5 yards to the CHEY34, NO PLAY. |
| Ship | 3-11 | at Chey34 | Timeout Shippensburg, clock 11:57. |
| Ship | 3-11 | at Chey34 | Chad DiFebbo pass complete to Mike Harris for 15 yards to the CHEY19, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Carl Meeks). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey19 | Kevin Marshall rush for no gain to the CHEY19 (Joseph Morris), PENALTY CHEY offside 5 yards to the CHEY14, NO PLAY. |
| Ship | 1-5 | at Chey14 | Mike Frenette rush for 4 yards to the CHEY10 (Ronnell Kennedy). |
| Ship | 2-1 | at Chey10 | Kevin Herod rush for no gain to the CHEY10 (Bryan Payne). |
| Ship | 3-1 | at Chey10 | Kevin Herod rush for 8 yards to the CHEY2, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Darryl Wilkins), PENALTY CHEY offside declined. |
| Ship | 1-G | at Chey02 | Mike Frenette rush for loss of 1 yard to the CHEY3 (Demel Chambers). |
| Ship | 2-G | at Chey03 | Mike Frenette rush for loss of 2 yards to the CHEY5 (Tim Hume). |
| Ship | 3-G | at Chey05 | Timeout Cheyney, clock 08:25. |
| Ship | 3-G | at Chey05 | Chad DiFebbo pass incomplete to Mark Rossi. |
| Ship | 4-G | at Chey05 | Kyler Ford field goal attempt from 23 GOOD, clock 08:12. |
| | | Shippensburg 10, Cheyney 7 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 28 yards, TOP 05:26 |
| | | Kyler Ford kickoff 55 yards to the CHEY15, John Newman return 10 yards to the CHEY25 (Mikal Sabree). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey25 | CHEYNEY drive start at 08:05. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey25 | Angel Rodriquez rush for 2 yards to the CHEY27. |
| Chey | 2-8 | at Chey27 | Dominic Crowell rush for 8 yards to the CHEY35, 1ST DOWN CHEY, out-of-bounds (J. McCollough). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey35 | Ron Hunter rush for loss of 2 yards to the CHEY33 (Andy Horn). |
| Chey | 2-12 | at Chey33 | Angel Rodriquez rush for 3 yards to the CHEY36 (Riley Bowen). |
| Chey | 3-9 | at Chey36 | Dominic Crowell rush for no gain to the CHEY36 (Josh Simmons). |
| Chey | 4-9 | at Chey36 | William Winter punt 41 yards to the SHIP23, downed. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 11 yards, TOP 03:25 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship23 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 04:40. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship23 | Chad DiFebbo pass complete to Mike Harris for 24 yards to the SHIP47, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Joseph Morris). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship47 | Kevin Herod rush for 4 yards to the CHEY49 (Bryan Payne). |
| Ship | 2-6 | at Chey49 | Mike Frenette rush for 7 yards to the CHEY42, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Jack Petion). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey42 | Chad DiFebbo pass incomplete to Mike Harris. |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Chey42 | Chad DiFebbo sacked for loss of 8 yards to the 50 yardline (Tim Hume). |
| Ship | 3-18 | at Ship50 | Chad DiFebbo sacked for loss of 10 yards to the SHIP40 (Tim Hume). |
| Ship | 4-28 | at Ship40 | Kyler Ford punt 40 yards to the CHEY20, John Newman return 1 yards to the CHEY21 (Cody Fleming). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 17 yards, TOP 03:22 |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey21 | CHEYNEY drive start at 01:18. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey21 | Angel Rodriquez rush for 11 yards to the CHEY32, 1ST DOWN CHEY, out-of-bounds (Nick Melusky). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey32 | John Newman rush for 5 yards to the CHEY37 (Cody Fleming). |
| Chey | 2-5 | at Chey37 | Angel Rodriquez rush for 2 yards to the CHEY39 (Nick Melusky). |
| Chey | 3-3 | at Chey39 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 18 yards, TOP 01:18 |
| | | Shippensburg 10, Cheyney 7 |
| Chey | 3-3 | at Chey39 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, CHEY ball on CHEY30. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 18 yards, TOP 01:18 |
| | | Tyler Wilkinson kickoff 52 yards to the SHIP18, Bryan Barley return 25 yards to the SHIP43 (Lamar Burrell), PENALTY SHIP unsportsmanlike conduct off-setting, PENALTY CHEY unsportsmanlike conduct off-setting. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship43 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 14:53. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship43 | Kevin Herod rush for 9 yards to the CHEY48 (Franklin Lyburn). |
| Ship | 2-1 | at Chey48 | Kevin Herod rush for 2 yards to the CHEY46, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Joe WInn). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey46 | Chad DiFebbo pass incomplete to Mike Harris. |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Chey46 | Mike Frenette rush for no gain to the CHEY46 (James Parker). |
| Ship | 3-10 | at Chey46 | Kevin Marshall rush for 12 yards to the CHEY34, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Ronnell Kennedy). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey34 | Kevin Herod rush for 4 yards to the CHEY30 (Joe WInn). |
| Ship | 2-6 | at Chey30 | Kevin Marshall rush for loss of 3 yards to the CHEY33 (Joe WInn). |
| Ship | 3-9 | at Chey33 | Chad DiFebbo pass complete to Mike Harris for 13 yards to the CHEY20, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Carl Meeks). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey20 | Kevin Marshall rush for no gain to the CHEY20 (Ronnell Kennedy). |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Chey20 | Kevin Herod rush for 9 yards to the CHEY11 (Ronnell Kennedy). |
| Ship | 3-1 | at Chey11 | Kevin Herod rush for 1 yard to the CHEY10, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Tim Hume). |
| Ship | 1-G | at Chey10 | Kevin Herod rush for 5 yards to the CHEY5 (Stan Banks). |
| Ship | 2-G | at Chey05 | Kevin Herod rush for 5 yards to the CHEY0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:32. |
| | | Kyler Ford kick attempt good. |
| | | Shippensburg 17, Cheyney 7 |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 57 yards, TOP 06:21 |
| | | Kyler Ford kickoff 49 yards to the CHEY21, John Newman return 7 yards to the CHEY28 (Kevin Herod). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey28 | CHEYNEY drive start at 08:26. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey28 | Angel Rodriquez sacked for loss of 8 yards to the CHEY20 (Zach Collins). |
| Chey | 2-18 | at Chey20 | John Newman rush for 1 yard to the CHEY21 (J. McCollough). |
| Chey | 3-17 | at Chey21 | Ron Hunter rush for loss of 4 yards to the CHEY17 (Riley Bowen;Vinnie Ranauto). |
| Chey | 4-21 | at Chey17 | William Winter punt 41 yards to the SHIP42, Bryan Barley return 0 yards to the SHIP42. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 11 yards, TOP 01:49 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship42 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 06:37. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship42 | Kevin Herod rush for 2 yards to the SHIP44 (Joe WInn). |
| Ship | 2-8 | at Ship44 | Kevin Herod rush for 3 yards to the SHIP47 (Jack Petion;Bryan Payne). |
| Ship | 3-5 | at Ship47 | Chad DiFebbo rush for 8 yards to the CHEY45, 1ST DOWN SHIP, out-of-bounds (Ben Thompson). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey45 | Mike Frenette rush for 2 yards to the CHEY43 (Bryan Payne). |
| Ship | 2-8 | at Chey43 | Fumble by recovered by SHIP Chad DiFebbo at CHEY43 (Darryl Wilkins). |
| Ship | 2-8 | at Chey43 | Chad DiFebbo rush for no gain to the CHEY43, fumble by Chad DiFebbo recovered by SHIP Chad DiFebbo at CHEY43. |
| Ship | 3-8 | at Chey43 | Chad DiFebbo pass intercepted by Stan Banks at the CHEY32, Stan Banks return 23 yards to the SHIP45 (Mike Frenette). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 15 yards, TOP 03:52 |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Ship45 | CHEYNEY drive start at 02:45. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Ship45 | John Newman rush for 1 yard to the SHIP44 (Cody Fleming). |
| Chey | 2-9 | at Ship44 | John Newman rush for no gain to the SHIP44, fumble by John Newman recovered by CHEY John Newman at SHIP44. |
| Chey | 3-9 | at Ship44 | Angel Rodriquez pass complete to Chris Singh for 19 yards to the SHIP25, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Cody Fleming). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Ship25 | Angel Rodriquez pass incomplete to Darnell Burton. |
| Chey | 2-10 | at Ship25 | Dominic Crowell rush for 4 yards to the SHIP21 (Nick Melusky), PENALTY CHEY illegal shift 5 yards to the SHIP30, NO PLAY. |
| Chey | 2-15 | at Ship30 | Angel Rodriquez pass complete to John Newman for 6 yards to the SHIP24 (Cody Fleming;Corey Hunt). |
| Chey | 3-9 | at Ship24 | Timeout Cheyney, clock 00:09. |
| Chey | 3-9 | at Ship24 | Angel Rodriquez pass complete to Travis Taltoan for 12 yards to the SHIP12, 1ST DOWN CHEY (Travis Proctor). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 33 yards, TOP 04:15 |
| | | Shippensburg 17, Cheyney 7 |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Ship12 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Ship12 | Angel Rodriquez rush for no gain to the SHIP12 (Josh Simmons). |
| Chey | 2-10 | at Ship12 | Angel Rodriquez pass incomplete to Travis Taltoan. |
| Chey | 3-10 | at Ship12 | Ron Hunter rush for no gain to the SHIP12 (Cody Fleming). |
| Chey | 4-10 | at Ship12 | Tyler Wilkinson field goal attempt from 30 GOOD, clock 13:30. |
| | | Shippensburg 17, Cheyney 10 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 33 yards, TOP 04:15 |
| | | Tyler Wilkinson kickoff 50 yards to the SHIP20, Bryan Barley return 16 yards to the SHIP36 (Norm Belton). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship36 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 13:23. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship36 | Kevin Herod rush for 6 yards to the SHIP42 (Darryl Wilkins). |
| Ship | 2-4 | at Ship42 | Kevin Herod rush for no gain to the SHIP42 (Joseph Morris). |
| Ship | 3-4 | at Ship42 | Chad DiFebbo pass complete to Mike Harris for 10 yards to the CHEY48, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Joseph Morris). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey48 | Kevin Herod rush for 4 yards to the CHEY44 (Jack Petion). |
| Ship | 2-6 | at Chey44 | Kevin Marshall rush for no gain to the CHEY44 (Stan Banks). |
| Ship | 3-6 | at Chey44 | Chad DiFebbo sacked for loss of 8 yards to the SHIP48 (Jack Petion;James Parker), fumble by Chad DiFebbo recovered by SHIP Dave Fremont at 50 yardline (Joe WInn). |
| Ship | 4-12 | at Ship50 | Kyler Ford punt 50 yards to the CHEY0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 14 yards, TOP 03:33 |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey20 | CHEYNEY drive start at 09:50. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey20 | Ron Hunter rush for no gain to the CHEY20 (Antoine Parks). |
| Chey | 2-10 | at Chey20 | Angel Rodriquez pass incomplete to Dominic Crowell (J. McCollough). |
| Chey | 3-10 | at Chey20 | Angel Rodriquez pass complete to Chris Singh for 20 yards to the CHEY40, 1ST DOWN CHEY (M. Sammons). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey40 | Dominic Crowell rush for loss of 3 yards to the CHEY37 (Vinnie Ranauto). |
| Chey | 2-13 | at Chey37 | Angel Rodriquez rush for no gain to the CHEY37, fumble by Angel Rodriquez recovered by SHIP Vinnie Ranauto at CHEY34. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 14 yards, TOP 01:35 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey34 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 08:15. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey34 | Chad DiFebbo pass incomplete to Mike Harris (Stan Banks). |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Chey34 | Kevin Herod rush for 3 yards to the CHEY31 (Ben Thompson). |
| Ship | 3-7 | at Chey31 | Chad DiFebbo pass complete to Mike Frenette for 29 yards to the CHEY2, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Stan Banks). |
| Ship | 1-G | at Chey02 | Mike Frenette rush for 2 yards to the CHEY0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 07:13. |
| | | Kyler Ford kick attempt good. |
| | | Shippensburg 24, Cheyney 10 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 34 yards, TOP 01:02 |
| | | Kyler Ford kickoff 70 yards to the CHEY0, Kareem Shelton return 23 yards to the CHEY23 (Joel Petersheim). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey23 | CHEYNEY drive start at 07:06. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey23 | Angel Rodriquez rush for no gain to the CHEY23 (Vinnie Ranauto). |
| Chey | 2-10 | at Chey23 | Angel Rodriquez pass incomplete to John Newman (Travis Proctor). |
| Chey | 3-10 | at Chey23 | Angel Rodriquez pass complete to Ron Hunter for loss of 3 yards to the CHEY20 (Zach Collins). |
| Chey | 4-13 | at Chey20 | Timeout Cheyney, clock 05:40. |
| Chey | 4-13 | at Chey20 | William Winter punt 22 yards to the CHEY42, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 3 yards, TOP 01:35 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey42 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 05:31. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey42 | Kevin Herod rush for 7 yards to the CHEY35 (Ben Thompson). |
| Ship | 2-3 | at Chey35 | Roshaan McCain rush for 1 yard to the CHEY34 (Franklin Lyburn). |
| Ship | 3-2 | at Chey34 | PENALTY CHEY offside 5 yards to the CHEY29, 1ST DOWN SHIP. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Chey29 | Kevin Herod rush for 2 yards to the CHEY27 (Franklin Lyburn). |
| Ship | 2-8 | at Chey27 | Mike Frenette rush for 1 yard to the CHEY26 (Bryan Payne), PENALTY SHIP holding 10 yards to the CHEY36. |
| Ship | 2-17 | at Chey36 | 2nd and 17. |
| Ship | 2-17 | at Chey36 | PENALTY SHIP false start 5 yards to the CHEY41. |
| Ship | 2-22 | at Chey41 | Chad DiFebbo pass complete to Kevin Marshall for 21 yards to the CHEY20 (Joseph Morris). |
| Ship | 3-1 | at Chey20 | Timeout Cheyney, clock 01:31. |
| Ship | 3-1 | at Chey20 | Kevin Herod rush for loss of 1 yard to the CHEY21 (James Parker). |
| Ship | 4-2 | at Chey21 | Timeout Shippensburg, clock 00:44. |
| Ship | 4-2 | at Chey21 | Chad DiFebbo pass complete to Mark Rossi for 21 yards to the CHEY0, 1ST DOWN SHIP, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:35. |
| | | Kyler Ford kick attempt good. |
| | | Shippensburg 31, Cheyney 10 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 42 yards, TOP 04:56 |
| | | Kyler Ford kickoff 59 yards to the CHEY11, John Newman return 26 yards to the CHEY37 (Kyler Ford). |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey37 | CHEYNEY drive start at 00:28. |
| Chey | 1-10 | at Chey37 | Angel Rodriquez pass incomplete to Darnell Burton (Mikal Sabree). |
| Chey | 2-10 | at Chey37 | Angel Rodriquez pass complete to John Newman for 9 yards to the CHEY46 (Josh Simmons). |
| Chey | 3-1 | at Chey46 | Angel Rodriquez pass incomplete to John Newman. |
| Chey | 4-1 | at Chey46 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 00:28 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Shippensburg 31, Cheyney 10 |