| | | Shippensburg wins the toss and elects to receive |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship35 | MILL ball on MILL35. |
| | | Evan Stahl kickoff 51 yards to the SHIP14, Sheldon Mayer return 15 yards to the SHIP29 (Alpha Kahn). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship29 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Trevor Harman for 17 yards to the SHIP46, 1ST DOWN SHIP, out-of-bounds (Rasheed Johnson). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship46 | Zach Zulli rush for 6 yards to the MILL48 (Jordan Rigby). |
| Ship | 2-4 | at Mill48 | Blair Brooks rush for 1 yard to the MILL47 (Ben Ludwig). |
| Ship | 3-3 | at Mill47 | Blair Brooks rush for 5 yards to the MILL42, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Reggie Slaton). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill42 | Zach Zulli pass incomplete (Jordan Rigby), QB hurry by Gilbert Ramos. |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Mill42 | Zach Zulli sacked for loss of 9 yards to the SHIP49 (Shawn Fahey). |
| Ship | 3-19 | at Ship49 | Zach Zulli rush for 12 yards to the MILL39 (Gilbert Ramos). |
| Ship | 4-7 | at Mill39 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Blair Brooks for 15 yards to the MILL24, 1ST DOWN SHIP, out-of-bounds (Rasheed Johnson). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill24 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Quran Kent for 2 yards to the MILL22 (Dan Miller). |
| Ship | 2-8 | at Mill22 | Zach Zulli rush for 6 yards to the MILL16 (Gilbert Ramos). |
| Ship | 3-2 | at Mill16 | Blair Brooks rush for 9 yards to the MILL7, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Rasheed Johnson). |
| Ship | 1-G | at Mill07 | Zach Zulli pass incomplete to Sheldon Mayer. |
| Ship | 2-G | at Mill07 | Trevor Harman rush for 1 yard to the MILL6 (Jordan Rigby). |
| Ship | 3-G | at Mill06 | Timeout Shippensburg, clock 09:00. |
| Ship | 3-G | at Mill06 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Sheldon Mayer for 6 yards to the MILL0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:55. |
| | | Drew Newcomer kick attempt good. |
| | | Shippensburg 7, Millersville 0 |
| | | Drive: 14 plays, 71 yards, TOP 06:11 |
| | | Nate Schmidt kickoff 38 yards to the MILL27, Ryon Freeman return 6 yards to the MILL33 (Shayne Watson). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill33 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 08:49. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill33 | Connor Casey pass complete to T. Petrovich for 22 yards to the SHIP45, 1ST DOWN MILL (James Cooper). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Ship45 | Ian Sadon rush for 2 yards to the SHIP43 (Brian Sourber;Cory Cowdery). |
| Mill | 2-8 | at Ship43 | Connor Casey pass complete to Connor Casey for 2 yards to the SHIP41 (Mike Goode). |
| Mill | 3-6 | at Ship41 | Connor Casey pass incomplete to Brent Collins (James Cooper). |
| Mill | 4-6 | at Ship41 | Evan Stahl punt 25 yards to the SHIP16, downed. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 26 yards, TOP 01:58 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship16 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 06:51. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship16 | Zach Zulli pass incomplete to Trevor Harman. |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Ship16 | Blair Brooks rush for 9 yards to the SHIP25 (Rasheed Johnson). |
| Ship | 3-1 | at Ship25 | Blair Brooks rush for 31 yards to the MILL44, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Rasheed Johnson), PENALTY MILL personal foul (Rasheed Johnson) 15 yards to the MILL29, 1ST DOWN SHIP. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill29 | 1st and 10. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill29 | Shannon Maura rush for 1 yard to the MILL28 (Josh Garnett;Marvin Gaskill). |
| Ship | 2-9 | at Mill28 | Zach Zulli pass incomplete to Quran Kent, dropped pass. |
| Ship | 3-9 | at Mill28 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Blair Brooks for no gain to the MILL28 (Ryan McIntyre), QB hurry by Reggie Slaton. |
| Ship | 4-9 | at Mill28 | Timeout Shippensburg, clock 04:50. |
| Ship | 4-9 | at Mill28 | Drew Newcomer field goal attempt from 46 MISSED - short, spot at MILL28, clock 04:44. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 56 yards, TOP 02:07 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill28 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 04:44. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill28 | Connor Casey pass complete to Mark Damirgian for 13 yards to the MILL41, 1ST DOWN MILL (Avery Coleman). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill41 | Connor Casey pass incomplete to Dominic Sanders, QB hurry by Cortlin Dell. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill41 | Ian Sadon rush for 1 yard to the MILL42 (Dainen Green;James Brennan). |
| Mill | 3-9 | at Mill42 | Connor Casey sacked for loss of 15 yards to the MILL27 (Jake Metz;Mike Schmidt). |
| Mill | 4-24 | at Mill27 | Evan Stahl punt 31 yards to the SHIP42, fair catch by Shannon Maura. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 02:09 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship42 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 02:35. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship42 | Chris Lawshe at QB for Shippensburg. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship42 | Chris Lawshe rush for 3 yards to the SHIP45 (Jody Dodds). |
| Ship | 2-7 | at Ship45 | Zach Zulli at QB for Shippensburg. |
| Ship | 2-7 | at Ship45 | Shannon Maura rush for 1 yard to the SHIP46 (Rasheed Johnson;Richard Karb). |
| Ship | 3-6 | at Ship46 | PENALTY SHIP false start (Jason Brady) 5 yards to the SHIP41. |
| Ship | 3-11 | at Ship41 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Blair Brooks for 9 yards to the 50 yardline, out-of-bounds (Matt Brinser). |
| Ship | 4-2 | at Ship50 | Shannon Maura rush for loss of 3 yards to the SHIP47 (Dean May;Matt Brinser). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 5 yards, TOP 01:40 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Ship47 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 00:55. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Ship47 | Connor Casey pass complete to Dominic Sanders for 37 yards to the SHIP10, 1ST DOWN MILL (Avery Coleman). |
| Mill | 1-G | at Ship10 | Ian Sadon rush for 3 yards to the SHIP7 (Cortlin Dell;Mike Goode). |
| Mill | 2-G | at Ship07 | Connor Casey pass incomplete to Brent Collins, QB hurry by Brian Sourber. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 40 yards, TOP 01:08 |
| | | Shippensburg 7, Millersville 0 |
| Mill | 3-G | at Ship07 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mill | 3-G | at Ship07 | Connor Casey pass incomplete to Tre Maxwell. |
| Mill | 4-G | at Ship07 | Evan Stahl field goal attempt from 24 GOOD, clock 14:53. |
| | | Shippensburg 7, Millersville 3 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 40 yards, TOP 01:08 |
| | | Evan Stahl kickoff 57 yards to the SHIP8, Sheldon Mayer return 22 yards to the SHIP30 (Alpha Kahn). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship30 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 14:47. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship30 | Blair Brooks rush for 8 yards to the SHIP38 (Jordan Rigby). |
| Ship | 2-2 | at Ship38 | Blair Brooks rush for no gain to the SHIP38 (Josh Garnett). |
| Ship | 3-2 | at Ship38 | Blair Brooks rush for 8 yards to the SHIP46, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Joey Pham). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship46 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Kyle Kush for 12 yards to the MILL42, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Reggie Slaton). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill42 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Kyle Kush for 9 yards to the MILL33, out-of-bounds. |
| Ship | 2-1 | at Mill33 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Daniel Wheeler for 7 yards to the MILL26, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Dean May). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill26 | Zach Zulli rush for 2 yards to the MILL24 (Ryan McIntyre). |
| Ship | 2-8 | at Mill24 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Daniel Wheeler for 10 yards to the MILL14, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Dean May). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill14 | Blair Brooks rush for 7 yards to the MILL7 (Dean May;Rasheed Johnson). |
| Ship | 2-3 | at Mill07 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Sheldon Mayer for 7 yards to the MILL0, 1ST DOWN SHIP, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:30. |
| | | Drew Newcomer kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by T. Petrovich). |
| | | Shippensburg 13, Millersville 3 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 70 yards, TOP 03:22 |
| | | Nate Schmidt kickoff 50 yards to the MILL15, Brent Collins return 5 yards to the MILL20 (B. Hollister). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill20 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 11:25. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill20 | Connor Casey pass incomplete to Dominic Sanders. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill20 | Connor Casey pass complete to M. Reichenbach for 5 yards to the MILL25 (Tyriq Kershaw). |
| Mill | 3-5 | at Mill25 | Connor Casey pass complete to M. Reichenbach for 19 yards to the MILL44, 1ST DOWN MILL, out-of-bounds. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill44 | Ian Sadon rush for 6 yards to the 50 yardline (Phil Boyd). |
| Mill | 2-4 | at Mill50 | Ian Sadon rush for loss of 3 yards to the MILL47 (Tyriq Kershaw). |
| Mill | 3-7 | at Mill47 | Connor Casey rush for 10 yards to the SHIP43, 1ST DOWN MILL, out-of-bounds (Dainen Green). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Ship43 | Ian Sadon rush for 2 yards to the SHIP41 (Cortlin Dell). |
| Mill | 2-8 | at Ship41 | Connor Casey pass incomplete to T. Petrovich. |
| Mill | 3-8 | at Ship41 | Timeout Millersville, clock 07:41. |
| Mill | 3-8 | at Ship41 | Curtis Frye sacked for loss of 4 yards to the SHIP45 (Jake Metz). |
| Mill | 4-12 | at Ship45 | Evan Stahl punt 45 yards to the SHIP0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 35 yards, TOP 04:37 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship20 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 06:48. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship20 | Chris Lawshe at QB for Shippensburg. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship20 | Chris Lawshe rush for 4 yards to the SHIP24 (Rasheed Johnson). |
| Ship | 2-6 | at Ship24 | Zach Zulli at QB for Shippensburg. |
| Ship | 2-6 | at Ship24 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Daniel Wheeler for 15 yards to the SHIP39, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Kenneth Brown). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship39 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Blair Brooks for 8 yards to the SHIP47 (Jordan Rigby). |
| Ship | 2-2 | at Ship47 | Chris Lawshe rush for 2 yards to the SHIP49, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Ryan McIntyre). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship49 | Chris Lawshe at QB for Shippensburg. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship49 | PENALTY SHIP false start (Jason Brady) 5 yards to the SHIP44. |
| Ship | 1-15 | at Ship44 | Blair Brooks rush for no gain to the SHIP44 (Marvin Gaskill). |
| Ship | 2-15 | at Ship44 | Zach Zulli pass incomplete to Trevor Harman (Kenneth Brown). |
| Ship | 3-15 | at Ship44 | Zach Zulli rush for 5 yards to the SHIP49 (Gilbert Ramos). |
| Ship | 4-10 | at Ship49 | Nate Schmidt punt 38 yards to the MILL13, fair catch by Dominic Sanders. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 29 yards, TOP 03:49 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill13 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 02:59. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill13 | Curtis Frye pass complete to T. Petrovich for 37 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN MILL, out-of-bounds (Cortlin Dell). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill50 | Ian Sadon rush for 4 yards to the SHIP46 (Cory Cowdery;Brian Sourber). |
| Mill | 2-6 | at Ship46 | Connor Casey sacked for loss of 10 yards to the MILL44 (Dainen Green). |
| Mill | 3-16 | at Mill44 | Connor Casey pass incomplete to Brent Collins. |
| Mill | 4-16 | at Mill44 | Evan Stahl punt 41 yards to the SHIP15, downed. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 31 yards, TOP 02:02 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship15 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 00:57. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship15 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Trevor Harman for 9 yards to the SHIP24, out-of-bounds (Dean May). |
| Ship | 2-1 | at Ship24 | PENALTY SHIP false start (Marc Ranaudo) 5 yards to the SHIP19. |
| Ship | 2-6 | at Ship19 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Kyle Kush for 19 yards to the SHIP38, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Rasheed Johnson). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship38 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Kyle Kush for 3 yards to the SHIP41 (Dan Miller). |
| Ship | 2-7 | at Ship41 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Trevor Harman for 59 yards to the MILL0, 1ST DOWN SHIP, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:14. |
| | | Drew Newcomer kick attempt good. |
| | | Shippensburg 20, Millersville 3 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 85 yards, TOP 00:46 |
| | | Nate Schmidt kickoff 32 yards to the MILL33, James Fielder return 0 yards to the MILL33, fumble by James Fielder recovered by MILL James Fielder at MILL33. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill33 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 00:11. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill33 | PENALTY SHIP illegal formation 5 yards to the MILL38. |
| Mill | 1-5 | at Mill38 | 1st and 10. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill38 | Connor Casey pass incomplete, QB hurry by Cortlin Dell. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill38 | Connor Casey pass incomplete. |
| Mill | 3-10 | at Mill38 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 5 yards, TOP 00:11 |
| | | Shippensburg 20, Millersville 3 |
| Mill | 3-10 | at Mill38 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, SHIP ball on SHIP35. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 5 yards, TOP 00:11 |
| | | Nate Schmidt kickoff 58 yards to the MILL7, Brent Collins return 14 yards to the MILL21 (Kyle Karpinski). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill21 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 14:54. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill21 | Dominic Sanders rush for no gain to the MILL21 (Brian Sourber). |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill21 | PENALTY MILL false start (Neil Moloney) 5 yards to the MILL16. |
| Mill | 2-15 | at Mill16 | Connor Casey pass incomplete to Dominic Sanders (Jake Metz). |
| Mill | 3-15 | at Mill16 | Connor Casey pass incomplete to Dominic Sanders (Mike Goode). |
| Mill | 4-15 | at Mill16 | Evan Stahl punt 42 yards to the SHIP42, Sheldon Mayer return 11 yards to the MILL47 (Brian Kelly). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 5 yards, TOP 01:17 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill47 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 13:37. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill47 | Blair Brooks rush for 8 yards to the MILL39 (David Rene). |
| Ship | 2-2 | at Mill39 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Trevor Harman for 4 yards to the MILL35, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Reggie Slaton). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill35 | Zach Zulli pass incomplete to Sheldon Mayer. |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Mill35 | Blair Brooks rush for 2 yards to the MILL33 (Reggie Slaton;Ben Ludwig). |
| Ship | 3-8 | at Mill33 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Alex Kuljian for 12 yards to the MILL21, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Jordan Rigby). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill21 | Zach Zulli rush for 8 yards to the MILL13 (Dean May). |
| Ship | 2-2 | at Mill13 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Blair Brooks for 9 yards to the MILL4, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Matt Brinser). |
| Ship | 1-G | at Mill04 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Quran Kent for 4 yards to the MILL0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:18. |
| | | Drew Newcomer kick attempt good. |
| | | Shippensburg 27, Millersville 3 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 47 yards, TOP 02:27 |
| | | Nate Schmidt kickoff 65 yards to the MILL0, David Coates return 40 yards to the MILL40 (Nate Schmidt). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill40 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 11:10. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill40 | Curtis Frye at QB for Millersville. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill40 | Curtis Frye pass complete to Dominic Sanders for 5 yards to the MILL45 (Cortlin Dell). |
| Mill | 2-5 | at Mill45 | Ian Sadon rush for loss of 1 yard to the MILL44 (Brian Sourber). |
| Mill | 3-6 | at Mill44 | Curtis Frye pass incomplete (Chad Miller). |
| Mill | 4-6 | at Mill44 | Evan Stahl punt 41 yards to the SHIP15, Sheldon Mayer return 16 yards to the SHIP31 (Cory Harrison;Reggie Slaton). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 01:28 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship31 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 09:42. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship31 | Blair Brooks rush for 2 yards to the SHIP33 (Josh Garnett). |
| Ship | 2-8 | at Ship33 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Sheldon Mayer for 22 yards to the MILL45, 1ST DOWN SHIP. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill45 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Trevor Harman for 9 yards to the MILL36, out-of-bounds (Dean May). |
| Ship | 2-1 | at Mill36 | Kyle Kush pass incomplete to Trevor Harman. |
| Ship | 3-1 | at Mill36 | Blair Brooks rush for 6 yards to the MILL30, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Rasheed Johnson). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill30 | Zach Zulli pass incomplete to Trevor Harman. |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Mill30 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Kyle Kush for 9 yards to the MILL21. |
| Ship | 3-1 | at Mill21 | Chris Lawshe rush for 3 yards to the MILL18, 1ST DOWN SHIP (Rasheed Johnson). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill18 | Chris Lawshe rush for no gain to the MILL18 (Marvin Gaskill). |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Mill18 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Trevor Harman for 8 yards to the MILL10, out-of-bounds (Dean May). |
| Ship | 3-2 | at Mill10 | Chris Lawshe pass incomplete to Trevor Harman. |
| Ship | 4-2 | at Mill10 | Zach Zulli pass incomplete to Sheldon Mayer. |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 59 yards, TOP 03:27 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill10 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 06:15. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill10 | Ian Sadon rush for 6 yards to the MILL16 (Tyriq Kershaw). |
| Mill | 2-4 | at Mill16 | PENALTY MILL false start (Neil Moloney) 5 yards to the MILL11. |
| Mill | 2-9 | at Mill11 | Ian Sadon rush for no gain to the MILL11 (James Brennan;Brian Sourber). |
| Mill | 3-9 | at Mill11 | Curtis Frye sacked for loss of 4 yards to the MILL7 (Chase Fleming). |
| Mill | 4-13 | at Mill07 | Evan Stahl punt 33 yards to the MILL40, Sheldon Mayer return 24 yards to the MILL16, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 3 yards, TOP 02:34 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill16 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 03:41. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Mill16 | Blair Brooks rush for 4 yards to the MILL12 (Jordan Rigby). |
| Ship | 2-6 | at Mill12 | Blair Brooks rush for 4 yards to the MILL8 (Ben Ludwig). |
| Ship | 3-2 | at Mill08 | Blair Brooks rush for 8 yards to the MILL0, 1ST DOWN SHIP, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:41. |
| | | Drew Newcomer kick attempt good. |
| | | Shippensburg 34, Millersville 3 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 16 yards, TOP 01:06 |
| | | Nate Schmidt kickoff 62 yards to the MILL3, Cory Harrison return 16 yards to the MILL19 (Shayne Watson). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill19 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 02:35. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill19 | Connor Casey pass complete to Dominic Sanders for 8 yards to the MILL27 (Mike Goode). |
| Mill | 2-2 | at Mill27 | Connor Casey pass incomplete to Dominic Sanders (Tyriq Kershaw). |
| Mill | 3-2 | at Mill27 | Connor Casey pass complete to M. Reichenbach for 1 yard to the MILL28. |
| Mill | 4-1 | at Mill28 | Ian Sadon rush for 1 yard to the MILL29, 1ST DOWN MILL (James Cooper;Cortlin Dell). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill29 | Connor Casey pass incomplete to Dominic Sanders, QB hurry by Jake Metz. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill29 | Connor Casey pass incomplete, QB hurry by Brian Sourber. |
| Mill | 3-10 | at Mill29 | Connor Casey pass complete to Brent Collins for 18 yards to the MILL47, 1ST DOWN MILL (D.J. Burkey). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill47 | Connor Casey pass incomplete to Ian Sadon. |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill47 | Connor Casey sacked for loss of 4 yards to the MILL43 (B. Hollister). |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 24 yards, TOP 04:53 |
| | | Shippensburg 34, Millersville 3 |
| Mill | 3-14 | at Mill43 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mill | 3-14 | at Mill43 | Connor Casey pass complete to T. Petrovich for 16 yards to the SHIP41, 1ST DOWN MILL (James Cooper). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Ship41 | Connor Casey rush for 2 yards to the SHIP39, out-of-bounds. |
| Mill | 2-8 | at Ship39 | Ian Sadon rush for 4 yards to the SHIP35 (B. Hollister;James Brennan). |
| Mill | 3-4 | at Ship35 | Connor Casey sacked for loss of 10 yards to the SHIP45 (Jake Metz), PENALTY SHIP face mask (Jake Metz) 15 yards to the SHIP30, 1ST DOWN MILL. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Ship30 | 1st and 10. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Ship30 | Curtis Frye pass complete to Dominic Sanders for 30 yards to the SHIP0, 1ST DOWN MILL, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:54. |
| | | Evan Stahl kick attempt good. |
| | | Shippensburg 34, Millersville 10 |
| | | Drive: 14 plays, 81 yards, TOP 04:53 |
| | | Evan Stahl kickoff 54 yards to the SHIP11, Blair Brooks return 89 yards to the MILL0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:42. |
| | | Drew Newcomer kick attempt good. |
| | | Shippensburg 41, Millersville 10 |
| | | Nate Schmidt kickoff 60 yards to the MILL5, David Coates return 18 yards to the MILL23 (Trevor Mack), PENALTY MILL holding 10 yards to the MILL13, 1st and 10, MILL ball on MILL13. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill13 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 12:34. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill13 | Curtis Frye pass complete to T. Petrovich for 4 yards to the MILL17 (Mike Goode). |
| Mill | 2-6 | at Mill17 | Curtis Frye sacked for loss of 3 yards to the MILL14 (Cory Cowdery). |
| Mill | 3-9 | at Mill14 | Curtis Frye pass incomplete to T. Petrovich, QB hurry by Dainen Green. |
| Mill | 4-9 | at Mill14 | Evan Stahl punt 45 yards to the SHIP41, Sheldon Mayer return 0 yards to the SHIP41 (Evan Stahl), PENALTY SHIP IB declined, PENALTY SHIP holding 10 yards to the SHIP31, 1st and 10, SHIP ball on SHIP31. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:46 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship31 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 10:48. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship31 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Quran Kent for 17 yards to the SHIP48, 1ST DOWN SHIP, out-of-bounds (Dean May). |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship48 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Daniel Wheeler for 7 yards to the MILL45 (David Rene). |
| Ship | 2-3 | at Mill45 | Zach Zulli pass complete to Trevor Harman for 45 yards to the MILL0, 1ST DOWN SHIP, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:03. |
| | | Drew Newcomer kick attempt good. |
| | | Shippensburg 48, Millersville 10 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 69 yards, TOP 00:45 |
| | | Nate Schmidt kickoff 65 yards to the MILL0, touchback. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill25 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 10:03. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill25 | Ian Sadon rush for 10 yards to the MILL35, 1ST DOWN MILL (D.J. Burkey). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill35 | Curtis Frye pass complete to Tre Maxwell for 6 yards to the MILL41 (Chase Fleming). |
| Mill | 2-4 | at Mill41 | PENALTY MILL false start (Austin Neider) 5 yards to the MILL36. |
| Mill | 2-9 | at Mill36 | Curtis Frye pass complete to Ian Sadon for 3 yards to the MILL39 (Steve Owens), QB hurry by Shayne Watson. |
| Mill | 3-6 | at Mill39 | Curtis Frye pass incomplete to Mark Damirgian (B. Hollister), PENALTY SHIP pass interference (B. Hollister) 2 yards to the MILL41, 1ST DOWN MILL, NO PLAY. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill41 | Curtis Frye pass complete to Mark Damirgian for no gain to the MILL41 (Chase Fleming). |
| Mill | 2-10 | at Mill41 | Ian Sadon rush for loss of 2 yards to the MILL39 (B. Hollister;Chase Fleming). |
| Mill | 3-12 | at Mill39 | Curtis Frye pass incomplete to Kevin Porter, dropped pass. |
| Mill | 4-12 | at Mill39 | Evan Stahl punt 35 yards to the SHIP26, fair catch by Sheldon Mayer. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 14 yards, TOP 03:59 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship26 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 06:04. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship26 | Shannon Maura rush for no gain to the SHIP26 (Matt Brinser;Ryan McIntyre). |
| Ship | 2-10 | at Ship26 | Shannon Maura rush for 1 yard to the SHIP27 (Matt Brinser). |
| Ship | 3-9 | at Ship27 | Chris Lawshe pass incomplete to Alex Kuljian. |
| Ship | 4-9 | at Ship27 | Nate Schmidt punt 50 yards to the MILL23, Brent Collins return 2 yards to the MILL25 (Tyriq Kershaw;Mike Goode), PENALTY MILL IB 10 yards to the MILL15, 1st and 10, MILL ball on MILL15. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:41 |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill15 | MILLERSVILLE drive start at 04:23. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill15 | David Coates rush for 7 yards to the MILL22 (Steve Owens;Kurt Walker). |
| Mill | 2-3 | at Mill22 | David Coates rush for 3 yards to the MILL25, 1ST DOWN MILL (Chad Miller;Chase Fleming). |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill25 | David Coates pass incomplete, PENALTY SHIP personal foul 15 yards to the MILL40, 1ST DOWN MILL, NO PLAY. |
| Mill | 1-10 | at Mill40 | Hakeem Johnson rush for loss of 2 yards to the MILL38 (Chase Fleming). |
| Mill | 2-12 | at Mill38 | Curtis Frye pass complete to M. Reichenbach for 1 yard to the MILL39 (B. Hollister). |
| Mill | 3-11 | at Mill39 | Curtis Frye pass incomplete to James Fielder. |
| Mill | 4-11 | at Mill39 | Evan Stahl punt 33 yards to the SHIP28, fair catch by Sheldon Mayer. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 24 yards, TOP 02:55 |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship28 | SHIPPENSBURG drive start at 01:28. |
| Ship | 1-10 | at Ship28 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the SHIP27. |
| Ship | 2-11 | at Ship27 | TEAM rush for loss of 2 yards to the SHIP25. |
| Ship | 3-13 | at Ship25 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the SHIP24. |
| Ship | 4-14 | at Ship24 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 01:28 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Shippensburg 48, Millersville 10 |